Pepper Mill - West Chester Menu
Welcome to Pepper Mill - West Chester, a cherished institution located at 813 N Chester Rd, West Chester, PA. Despite its building showing signs of age, the heart of this restaurant beats with vibrant flavors and beloved dishes that keep customers returning, some for over 30 years.
The menu is a delightful mix of Italian classics and hearty American favorites. Patrons rave about their cheesesteaks, featuring tender, flavorful meat and perfectly crisp rolls. The Cajun fries and onion rings complement any meal, served hot and fresh.
Guests also enjoy an array of burgers, from classic American to zesty Chipotle, each satisfying with generous portions. The inviting atmosphere and friendly staff create a welcoming experience, making it a hidden gem for both locals and visitors.
Pepper Mill may need some TLC, but its commitment to delicious, comforting food remains unmatched. Don't miss the chance to savor this historic dining experience!
Apps/Sides
Salad
Steak
Chicken Steak
Roast Pork
Cutlet, Sausage & Meatball
Burger
Sandwich
Hoagie
Ice Cream
Chips / Snacks
"SIDE OF"
12" Sm Pizza
16" Lg Pizza
Small Stromboli
Large Stromboli
Catering Steak/Chicken
Catering Hoagies
Caterings Salads
Catering Sides
Tomato Pie *24 Hr Notice Required 48 Hr For Sundays*
Apps/Sides
French Fries, Crinkle Cut
US$4.15
Cheese Fries
US$6.25
Chicken Fingers
US$8.40
Chicken Finger Platter
US$10.97
Buffalo Tenders
US$8.40
Old Bay Fries, Crinkle Cut
US$4.45
Old Bay Fries W/Chz
US$6.55
Pizza Fries
US$6.75
Onion Rings
US$5.20
Cajun Fries, Crinkle Cut
US$4.45
Cajun Fries W/ Chz
US$6.55
Potato Chunks
US$5.99
Mozzarella Sticks
US$7.50
Jalapeño Poppers
US$6.25
Breaded Zucchini
US$5.20
10 Buffalo Wings Boneless/Bone In
US$11.99
Potato Chunks W/ Chz
US$8.35
Broccoli Cheddar & Bacon Poppers
US$6.25
Fried Raviolis
US$6.00
Soup Of The Day
US$3.40
Cole Slaw
US$1.25
Garden Salad
US$8.99
Caesar Salad
US$9.99
Cobb Salad
US$11.99
Tuna Salad Salad
US$11.99
Chicken Salad Salad
US$11.99
Waldorf Chicken Salad
US$11.99
Greek Salad
US$9.99
Chef Salad
US$12.99
Santa Fe Salad
US$11.99
Flaming Rooster Salad
US$11.99
Wedge Salad
US$11.99
Signature Salad
US$11.99
Side Garden Salad
US$6.25
Side Caesar Salad
US$7.49
Salad
Steak
Plain Steak
US$10.99
Cheesesteak
US$11.99
Premier Cheesesteak
US$11.99
Pizza Steak
US$11.99
The Grid Iron
US$11.99
Triple Cheesesteak
US$11.99
El Diablo
US$12.99
Super Jawn
US$12.99
Chicken Steak
US$11.99
Chicken Cheesesteak
US$11.99
South Of The Border
US$12.99
Buffalo Chicken Cheesesteak
US$12.99
Spicy Chicken Cheesesteak
US$12.99
Honey Sriracha Chicken
US$11.99
Chicken Steak
Roast Pork
Roast Pork Italiano
US$11.99
Roast Pork Soppressata Grinder
US$13.99
Italian Sausage Pepper & Onion
US$11.99
Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana
US$11.99
Chicken Cutlet Cordon Bleu
US$11.99
BLT Cutlet
US$11.99
Ranch Chicken Cutlet
US$10.99
Meatball Parmigiana
US$11.99
Greek Cutlet
US$11.99
Cutlet Italiano
US$13.99
Buffalo Cutlet Sandwich
US$11.99
Cutlet, Sausage & Meatball
Burger
Hamburger
US$8.99
Cheese Burger
US$9.99
Bacon Bleu Burger
US$10.99
Pizza Burger
US$9.99
Arizona Burger
US$10.99
Turkey Sandwich
US$9.99
Roast Beef
US$9.99
Ham & Cheese
US$9.99
Chicken Salad
US$10.49
Egg Salad
US$6.99
Club
US$10.99
BLT
US$8.99
Pepper & Egg
US$7.99
Albacore Tuna
US$10.49
Tuna Grill
US$10.49
Grilled Chicken
US$8.49
Grilled Cheese
US$5.99
Reuben
US$10.99
Grilled Veggie
US$9.99
Pork Roll
US$6.99
Hot Dog
US$6.99
Fire House Chicken
US$11.99
Sandwich
Hoagie
Italian Hoagie
US$11.99
Italian Special
US$11.99
Turkey Hoagie
US$10.99
Ham & Cheese Hoagie
US$11.99
Roast Beef Hoagie
US$11.99
Mixed Ch Hoagie
US$11.99
Rachel Hoagie
US$11.99
Roast Beef Horseradish Hoagie
US$11.99
Big Daddy Hoagie
US$12.99
El Camino
US$11.99
Chicken Salad Hoagie
US$12.99
Albacore Tuna Salad Hoagie
US$12.99
Blue Combo Hoagie
US$11.99
Chicken Salad & Apple
US$12.99
Chicken Caesar
US$11.99
Ham Dijonnaise Hoagie
US$11.99
16oz Sm Shake
US$4.55
16oz Sm Malt
US$4.55
16oz Sm Float
US$4.55
22oz Lg Shake
US$5.90
22oz Lg Malt
US$5.90
22oz Lg Float
US$5.90
1 Dip
US$2.70
2 Dip
US$3.90
3 Dip
US$5.15
4 Dip
US$6.45
Ice Cream
Chips / Snacks
LG Bag Of Chips
US$4.99
LG Bag Of Kettle Chips
US$5.29
SM Bag Of Chips
US$2.69
SM Bag Of Kettle Chips
US$2.69
Cookies
US$1.49
Peanut Chews
US$0.50
Spicy Meat Stix
US$0.69
SO Cherry Hot Pepper
US$0.00
SO Sweet Pepper
US$0.00
SO Pickles
US$0.99
SO BBQ
US$0.69
SO Honey Mustard
US$0.69
SO Sautéed Onions
US$0.00
SO Mayo
US$0.00
SO Banana Peppers
US$0.00
SO Blue Cheese
US$0.69
SO Ranch
US$0.69
SO Mushrooms
US$0.69
SO Ketchup
US$0.00
SO Red Sauce
US$0.65
SO Balsamic
US$0.69
SO Caesar
US$0.69
SO House Buffalo Sauce
US$0.85
SO House Honey Sriracha
US$0.69
SO Franks Hot
US$0.69
SO French
US$0.69
SO Russian
US$0.69
SO Sweet Chili
US$0.69
SO Lettuce
US$0.69
SO Tomato
US$0.69
SO Oil/Vinegar
US$0.00
SO Whiz
US$2.10
SO Jalapeño
US$0.00
SO Raw Onions
US$0.00
SO Long Hots
US$1.00
SO Oil
US$0.00
SO Vinegar
US$0.00
SO Anchovies
US$1.85
SO Parmesan
US$0.85
SO Relish
US$0.00
SO Yellow Mustard
US$0.00
SO Rasp Vin
US$0.69
SO Sautéed Green Pep
US$0.69
SO Avocado
US$1.25
SO Horseradish
US$0.85
SO Roasted Red Peppers
US$0.99
SO Au Jus
US$0.85
SO Horsey Sauce
US$0.69
SO Hoagie Roll
US$1.00
SO Garlic Bread
US$1.85
SO Blue Cheese Crumbles
US$0.99
SO Spicy Brown Mustard
US$0.50
"SIDE OF"
12" Sm Pizza
12" Sm Classic
US$12.99
12" Sm White
US$12.99
12" Sm Four Cheese
US$14.99
12" Sm Hawaiin
US$16.99
12" Sm Vegetable
US$16.99
12" Sm Sweet Basil
US$16.99
12" Sm Buffalo Chicken
US$16.99
12" Sm BBQ Chx Pizza
US$16.99
12" Sm Chris's White
US$17.99
12" Sm The Prime
US$18.99
12" Sm Take 5
US$18.99
Sm Dough Ball
US$2.50
16" Lg Classic
US$15.99
16" Lg White
US$15.99
16" Lg Four Cheese
US$15.99
16" Lg Hawaiin
US$21.99
16" Lg Vegetable
US$21.99
16" Lg Sweet Basil
US$21.99
16" Lg Buffalo Chicken
US$21.99
16" Lg BBQ Pizza
US$21.99
16" Lg Chris's White
US$23.99
16" Lg The Prime
US$24.99
16" Lg Take 5
US$24.99
Lg Dough Ball
US$4.80
Bkfst Quiche
US$17.80
16" Lg Pizza
Small Stromboli
Sm Cheesesteak Stromboli
US$14.99
Sm Chicken Cheesesteak Stromboli
US$14.99
Sm Blue Combo Stromboli
US$15.99
Sm Pepperoni And Cheese Stromboli
US$14.99
Sm Pizza Stromboli
US$14.99
Sm Buffalo Chicken Cheesesteak Stromboli
US$15.99
Sm Hot And Blue Stromboli
US$15.99
Sm Ham And Cheese Stromboli
US$14.99
Sm Reuben Stromboli
US$15.99
Sm Pizza Steak Stromboli
US$15.99
Sm Chicken Cordon Bleu Stromboli
US$15.99
Sm Italian Stromboli
US$15.99
Sm Vegetable Stromboli
US$15.99
Sm Tuna Stromboli
US$16.99
Sm Spinach & Garlic
US$14.99
Sm Chicken & Broccoli
US$14.99
Lg Cheesesteak Stromboli
US$19.99
Lg Chicken Cheesesteak Stromboli
US$19.99
Lg Blue Combo Stromboli
US$20.99
Lg Pepperoni And Cheese Stromboli
US$19.99
Lg Pizza Stromboli
US$19.99
Lg Buffalo Chicken Cheesesteak Stromboli
US$20.99
Lg Hot And Blue Stromboli
US$20.99
Lg Ham And Cheese Stromboli
US$19.99
Lg Reuben Stromboli
US$20.99
Lg Pizza Steak Stromboli
US$20.99
Lg Chicken Cordon Bleu Stromboli
US$20.99
Lg Italian Stromboli
US$20.99
Lg Vegetable Stromboli
US$20.99
Lg Premier Stromboli
US$20.99
Lg Tuna Stromboli
US$21.99
Lg Spinach & Garlic
US$19.99
Lg Chicken & Broccoli
US$19.99
Large Stromboli
Catering Steak/Chicken
6 C.Steak Or Chicken CS Tray
US$79.99
6 Half Cs Half Chx Tray
US$79.99
8 C.Steak Or Chicken CS Tray
US$101.99
8 Half Cs Half Chx Tray
US$101.99
3FT C.Steak Or Chicken CS **48HR Notice Required
US$175.00
4FT C.Steak Or Chicken CS **48HR Notice Required
US$199.99
6FT C.Steak Or Chicken CS **48HR Notice Required-Call For Price
6 Hoagie Tray
US$71.99
8 Hoagie Tray
US$95.99
3FT Hoagie **48HR Notice Required
US$99.99
4FT Hoagie **48HR Notice Required
US$139.99
6FT Hoagie **48HR Notice Required
US$179.99
Catering Hoagies
Caterings Salads
Catering Caesar
US$54.99
Catering Garden
US$54.99
LB Pasta Salad **Need 24HR Notice
US$6.50
LB Potato Salad **Need 24HR Notice
US$6.50
LB Chicken Salad
US$10.55
1/2 LB Chicken Salad
US$6.55
50 Buffalo Wings
US$54.99
Cups, Plates, Napkins, Utensils
Catering Sides
Tomato Pie *24 Hr Notice Required 48 Hr For Sundays*
Tomato Pie 18x24" *24 Hr Notice Required 48Hr For Sundays
US$38.99